If you liked A Bride for Donnigan (Women of the West (Sagebrush)) by Janette Oke,
here are some books like this:

Click on a title, author name or category to see similar books

Rose Galbraith

Grace Livingston Hill

Scotland / Christian Fiction / Love Stories / Christian Life

Info/Buy

Amish Country Crossroads: The Postcard, The Crossroad, and Sanctuary

Beverly Lewis, David Lewis

Pennsylvania Lancaster County / Widows / Postcards / Journalists / Blind Women / Bed And Breakfast Accommodations / Amish

Info/Buy

Emperor Mage (Immortals (Paperback))

Tamora Pierce

Magic / Good And Evil / Fantasy / Human Animal Communication / Paranormal Fiction

Info/Buy

In the Hand of the Goddess (Song of the Lioness (Paperback))

Tamora Pierce

Women Heroes / Young Adult Fiction / Sex Role / Disguise / Magic / Princes / Knights And Knighthood / Alanna (Fictitious Character : Pierce)

Info/Buy